The First Round of the
2011 Entertained Organizer New Network TV Show Tournament wrapped up last night. Before Round 2 kicks off tomorrow, lets review some of the highlights:
GAME 1: FREE AGENTS VS. UP ALL NIGHT
Up All Night took an early and commanding lead with it's great cast and mixup of traditional sitcom dynamics giving it a decided edge against the will they/won't they retread dynamic of the otherwise serviceable Free Agents. Up All Night looks to be a serious contender not just in the next round, but in the tournament as a whole.
GAME 2: 2 BROKE GIRLS VS. CHARLIE'S ANGELS
CBS's best new comedy
2 Broke Girls dominated over the remake of
Charlie's Angels which failed to justify it's existence over a slew of other action adventure shows competing for your attention. It's not bad per say, but it's the kind of show if you think you'll like it you probably will, but if you think you won't, you definitely won't. That said 2 Broke Girls faces some stiff competition in the Second Round Up against our next game winner.
GAME 3: NEW GIRL VS. WHITNEY
Fox's new comedy
New Girl blew the competition out of the water with Zooey Deschanel's adorkable humor. In fact NBC's
Whitney was in fierce competition to be the worst new show of the season until a late entrant stole the title out from under her. The whole jaded bitter woman thing is done much better on
2 Broke Girls and it'll be interesting to watch it and
New Girl go up against each other in the Second Round, especially as
New Girl deals with the replacement of cast member Damon Wayans Jr. by Lamorne Morris.
GAME 4: PERSON OF INTEREST VS. PRIME SUSPECT
These two well-pedigreed police procedurals were in a classic standoff against each other in Game 4. Ultimately NBC's
Prime Suspect carried the day do to it's future potential (though it's future may be brief if it doesn't increase it's ratings soon). It was also helped out by ratings success
Person of Interest backing the wooden Jim Caviezel as it's crazy homeless Batman lead. Prime Suspect will go on to face another gimmicky procedural in Round 2.
GAME 5: UNFORGETTABLE VS. A GIFTED MAN
While neither show truly grabbed me,
A Gifted Man's gimmick of a doctor literally haunted by the ghost of his dead ex-wife who wants him to complete her unfinished work by becoming a better man felt more likely to have longevity and story potential than
Unforgettable's a detective who can remember everything she's ever seen (EXCEPT WHO KILLED HER SISTER). Also
Unforgettable was originally titled
The Rememberer, and that's a name so bad that I will never get tired of mocking it. Seriously,
The Rememberer.
GAME 6: THE PLAYBOY CLUB VS. PAN AM
The battle of the Mad Men knockoffs, two 60's themed shows enter the ring, only one leaves. In this case the one left bleeding in the dirt would be
The Playboy Club which both fails in it's attempt to present objectifying women for money as a high water mark for feminism or make me interested in the mob murder subplot.
Pan Am juggles a lot of different plots but if it can find an even keel it has potential.
GAME 7: REVENGE VS. TERRA NOVA
Easily the two oddest new dramas of the season,
Revenge is a procedural based on the novel
Count of Monte Cristo, in which our protagonist gets revenge on a different Hamptonite she holds responsible for ruining her father's life. While
Terra Nova is about dinosaurs, time travel, and conspiracies involving dinosaurs and time travel. While I enjoyed both shows, the sci-fi nerd in me ultimately won out with the gorgeously shot and CGI-heavy
Terra Nova advancing to the next round.
GAME 8: SUBURGATORY VS. HOW TO BE A GENTLEMAN
How to Be a Gentleman was the single worst new pilot this season. It wasn't even bad by modern standards, but as a terrible 'wacky situation' sitcom of the 90s. Which is not to say that
Suburgatory merely won this match be default. It has some serious potential and sandwiched in the middle of ABCs Wednesday night comedy block just before
Modern Family (whose audience should like this too)
Suburgatory could be a big hit even if I do think it's a bit over the top in the pilot.
What's Up Next in Round 2:
 |
| Click for larger version |
GAME 1: 2 Broke Girls vs. New Girl, will settle once and for all whether I'm more drawn to sarcastic or dorky brunettes.
GAME 2: A Gifted Man vs. Prime Suspect, will decide whether I prefer police or medical procedurals.
GAME 3: Pan Am vs. Terra Nova, will answer the question of whether it's better to go back 50 or 50 million years when doing a period piece.
GAME 4: Suburgatory vs. Up All Night, will answer that age old question, which is funnier raising a teenager or dealing with a baby.
Be sure to tune in!